Exist BetterSign inGet started

article · Body

The breathing trainer and whether it is worth it

A small handheld trainer that makes breathing in hard work. In one study it firmed up the valve at the top of the stomach, which is the part a hiatus hernia loosens.

Article · Body · about eight minutes

Breathing in is done by the diaphragm, the sheet of muscle under the lungs. The gullet passes through a gap in that sheet on its way down to the stomach, which means the diaphragm is the outer half of the valve keeping the stomach shut. A hiatus hernia is the stomach pushing up through that gap. The gap has widened. The pinch has loosened. That is why reflux comes with it so often.

A breathing trainer is a mouthpiece with a numbered dial on it. Turn the dial up, the air has to be pulled in through a narrower opening, so the diaphragm is working against a load the way a bicep works against a dumbbell. Do it regularly for a few weeks, the muscle gets stronger. Nothing cleverer than that is going on.

Twenty people took part in the study that matters here. Ten trained three times a week for eight weeks while ten did nothing. In the ten who trained, the squeeze held by the valve when they were not eating went from 18.8 to 22.8, measured in the same units as blood pressure. Higher means a firmer valve. The ten who did not train did not move. Heartburn was less intense in the trained group. Throat clearing happened less.

Twenty people is a small study. What makes it worth knowing anyway is that nothing else short of surgery has been shown to change the valve's own squeeze rather than the symptoms sitting above it.

How hard to set the dial

The study measured how hard each person could pull air in, then set their dial at half of that, which is demanding without being impossible. At home, with no measuring kit, it gets set by feel instead. The NHS leaflets written for this device say the pull should feel sort of hard rather than agonising. Once it stops feeling like work, turn it up a number.

A session, the way the NHS teaches it

1

Sit upright somewhere you will not be interrupted for five minutes.

Slumping folds the diaphragm so it cannot pull properly.

2

Pinch your nose or wear the clip, then seal your lips around the mouthpiece.

Air sneaking in through the nose takes the load straight off.

3

Breathe all the way out. Pull one fast hard breath in through the device. Let it out slowly.

The pull is the repetition. The breath out is the rest between them.

4

Six of those, then rest a minute. Six more, rest 45 seconds. Then 30 seconds, then 15, then 5.

Thirty breaths in all. The rests shorten as the session goes on, which is where the work is.

5

Twice a day.

That is the protocol the device comes with. The reflux study used three sessions a week, so either is defensible.

Ask somebody before you buy one

This is the part most pages selling these leave out.

  • The maker's own precautions page puts abdominal hernia on a short list of conditions where the device is not recommended until medical clearance has been obtained from a health professional. Recent abdominal surgery is on the same list.
  • A hiatus hernia is a different thing from a hernia in the abdominal wall, so whether that line is meant to cover it is a question for a clinician rather than for a website.
  • Pulling hard against resistance raises the pressure inside the chest. Pressure is what pushes the stomach up through the gap in the first place.

So this is a short conversation with a GP or a physiotherapist before anything is ordered. Physiotherapists use these devices every week after chest surgery. It is a familiar request rather than an odd one.

If this does not help

Eight weeks is how long the study ran, so eight weeks is a fair trial. If nothing has shifted by then the valve may not be the part that is failing. Slow stomach emptying, bile coming up rather than acid, or a hernia large enough to need repair all feel much the same from the outside. A gastroenterologist can tell them apart with testing. A nutritional therapist can look at the emptying side of it without a referral.

Where to get it

Bought direct from the maker, or through a physiotherapist, who may have one already.

Free way in: slow belly breathing needs no device at all. It has its own randomised trials behind it for reflux, set out in your reading. Start there. The trainer then becomes a question for later rather than a purchase today.

Nobody has tested this in people with a large hiatus hernia. The reflux study never said how big anybody's was, which is the honest limit on all of it.

Written from the Exist Better knowledge base: the studies, books and thinkers behind each claim, read through every discipline we hold rather than one. Where the research is early or still argued, the page says so rather than rounding it up. How we decide what goes in.

© Exist Better 2026. All rights reserved.