article · Body
Most people with gut trouble are told it is IBS or that it is stress, then sent home. There is a great deal more known about this than that. Most of it points at something you can do this week.
Gut trouble is one of the commonest reasons people look for help. It is also one of the worst explained. The conversation often ends in three words: it is IBS. Or four: it is probably stress.
Both of those can be true. Neither is an explanation.
This is written for somebody whose gut has been a problem for months. It covers what it might be, what to rule out before you change anything, plus the handful of things worth trying that cost little or nothing.
If your gut and your mood are both struggling, the first question is which of them came first.
Not which is worse. That is almost always the one shouting loudest today. Which came first. And by how long.
If the gut went first and the flatness or the worry arrived months or years into it, the first move is at the gut end. If the mood went first, or the gut only plays up in hard weeks and eases on holiday whatever you eat, the first move is at the other end. If they arrived together, or you cannot remember, treat it as both and start with whatever is cheapest.
Most people cannot remember. There is no test for it. Two weeks of writing four things down answers it better than anything you could buy.
Why bother sorting it out? Because the same two symptoms in two people need opposite first steps. Treating the worry did nothing for one person and everything for another. Being handed the wrong first step twice is what convinces people that nothing will help.
IBS is real. It is common. It is not a label for nothing found.
Your gut has its own nervous system, around five hundred million nerve cells, wired to the brain by the vagus nerve. In IBS the signalling between the two appears to be amplified. Ordinary sensations can become painful and gut movement goes irregular. That is why strain makes it worse. It is also why it is not imagined.
One feature separates IBS from most of what it gets confused with: pain that eases or changes after you open your bowels. It is often cramping or spasm rather than a steady ache, low down and often on the left. Waking at night to go points away from it.
The parts nobody connects to the gut are worth saying out loud to your own doctor. Tiredness is reported by most people with IBS and almost never mentioned to the doctor treating the bowel. So is low dull backache. So are bladder symptoms, which get investigated separately by a different department. Nausea without vomiting. Early fullness at meals. Headache. Pain during sex, in women, which is rarely volunteered and rarely asked about.
Coeliac disease needs a blood test taken while you are still eating gluten. This is the mistake made most often. Cut the gluten out first and the test stops working.
It also turns up looking nothing like a gut problem. Iron that falls again every time the tablets stop, with no bleeding found. Bone thinning earlier than expected. An itchy blistering rash on the elbows, knees or buttocks. Numbness or tingling nobody can account for. Repeated miscarriage. Mildly raised liver enzymes with no other cause, which in most people go back to normal once gluten is out.
The damage is to the part of the intestine that absorbs, so the first thing to fail is whatever is hardest to absorb. Somebody can lose a great deal of absorbing surface before the gut itself complains.
Gastritis is inflammation of the stomach lining. It burns or gnaws high in the middle of the abdomen, below the breastbone. Eating often settles it for a while, then it returns an hour or two later. Waking in the night with it is common. So is feeling full very early in a meal, bloating high up rather than low down, belching, nausea without being sick.
Reflux is not the same thing, although the two get treated alike. Reflux burns upward behind the breastbone and is worse lying flat and after a big meal. Gastritis burns higher in the middle and is more tied to an empty stomach and to painkillers.
The parts nobody connects to it are the tiredness that has built up over months, breathlessness going upstairs, pale skin, brittle nails, hair coming out more than usual, restless legs at night. That is iron, because an inflamed lining absorbs it poorly and can ooze slowly. Tingling in the hands or feet, a sore smooth tongue, poor balance or fog is B12, because a lining that has thinned stops making the thing B12 needs in order to be absorbed at all.
What causes it is usually one of four things. Helicobacter pylori, a bacterium that lives in the stomach lining, which is testable and treatable and is the commonest cause worldwide. Anti-inflammatory painkillers: ibuprofen, naproxen, diclofenac, regular aspirin. That is the second commonest and the most reversible of them. Alcohol, heavily or regularly. Or an immune process attacking the lining, which is the one that leads to B12 deficiency and runs alongside thyroid disease.
Stress does not cause this. That belief is old and persistent. It can make an existing one feel considerably worse, which is a different claim.
Some things are never just gastritis. Vomiting blood, or vomit that looks like coffee grounds. Black tarry stool. Food sticking. Weight falling without trying. A lump in the upper abdomen. New indigestion starting after fifty-five. Any of those needs to be seen promptly.
Gastroparesis is the stomach emptying too slowly with nothing in the way. Food sits. You are full after a few mouthfuls, you are nauseated, you may be sick hours after eating.
Two things about it are rarely explained. The test should run for four hours rather than two, because the short version misses a meaningful number of people, so plenty have been told their stomach is fine on the strength of one. If you had a two-hour scan reported as normal and still cannot eat, that is worth raising.
And how slow the emptying looks on the scan predicts how ill somebody feels only loosely. Some people with badly delayed emptying manage. Some with a mild delay cannot finish a meal. That is not a flaw in the person. How sensitive the lining is, how the stomach relaxes to make room and how the brain reads those signals all count alongside the speed, which is why treatment aimed only at speeding the stomach up so often disappoints.
The recognised causes are diabetes, surgery that involved the vagus nerve including some reflux and weight-loss operations, a viral illness, connective tissue disease, Parkinson's, plus a number of medicines. The largest group of all is the one where no cause is found, which is not the same as there being none.
Weight loss, dehydration, or being sick so often that you cannot keep fluids down is not a diet problem. That needs assessing now.
This one is mistaken for IBS with diarrhoea for years at a time.
Bile acids are made in the liver to digest fat. They are normally reabsorbed near the end of the small intestine. When too many reach the colon they draw in water and push things along, which produces urgent watery stool. It is common after the gallbladder is removed and frequently missed.
There is a specific test for it and a specific treatment. Neither is available over a counter. If your diarrhoea started after gallbladder or bowel surgery, ask about this by name.
The pattern is distinctive enough to recognise. Stool that is yellow, loose, sometimes greasy and hard to flush. Urgency with very little warning. Worst in the morning, often several times before leaving the house, then settling later in the day. Dramatically worse after a fatty meal rather than mildly worse. Pain is usually there and is usually not the main complaint, which is one of the things that separates it from IBS.
And the part people do not say out loud: accidents. Adults very rarely mention this to anybody. It is one of the commonest reasons somebody stops leaving the house. It is a symptom rather than a humiliation. Saying it out loud changes what gets investigated.
Ask to be looked at for this whatever the rest of your picture looks like if your diarrhoea started after your gallbladder came out, if you have Crohn's affecting the last part of the small bowel or have had that part removed, if you have had radiotherapy to the pelvis or abdomen, or if you are strict with a gluten-free diet for coeliac disease and still have diarrhoea.
The gallbladder is a storage bag. The liver makes bile all the time, the gallbladder holds it and concentrates it, then squeezes when a fatty meal arrives.
Take the bag away and the liver carries on making bile. It arrives as a slow trickle instead of a well-timed delivery. Most people manage on that without difficulty. Two things follow for everybody else.
Large fatty meals become harder work, because the concentrated burst is not there to meet them. Spreading fat across smaller amounts more often usually handles it. This is one of the few things here that genuinely improves with time, as the bile duct adapts.
And bile arriving when there is no food to work on carries on into the large bowel, where it irritates. That is bile acid diarrhoea. It is common after this operation, there is a test for it and there is a treatment that works well. It is also mistaken for IBS extremely often, which is how somebody ends up with years of the wrong advice. Ask about bile acid malabsorption by name, because that is the phrase that gets the right test.
One thing nobody mentions. Bile matters for absorbing fat and the fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E and K. Where fat digestion has been poor for years those are worth checking rather than assuming, vitamin D in particular.
Inflammatory bowel disease and IBS can describe themselves almost identically in one sentence. Crohn's disease can appear anywhere from the mouth to the anus and goes through the whole thickness of the bowel wall. Ulcerative colitis affects the colon only and stays in the lining, which is why it bleeds so characteristically.
A stool test called faecal calprotectin is the cheap thing that separates the two. Guidance asks for it before IBS is accepted as the answer in anybody with blood, weight loss, fever or waking at night to open their bowels. Do not accept IBS where there is blood.
And the symptoms are not only bowel symptoms, which is the commonest reason somebody is told they have something else for years. A quarter to a half of people get things elsewhere. Tiredness out of all proportion, which people rank as the worst symptom of the lot. Joint pain and swelling. Mouth ulcers that keep coming back. Sore red eyes or light sensitivity, which needs seeing promptly. Tender red lumps on the shins. Iron that will not stay up whatever you take.
People bring the bowel part to the appointment and leave the rest out, because none of it seems connected to a bowel problem. Listing them together in one appointment does more than any of them does alone.
Waking in the night to open your bowels almost never happens in IBS and matters a great deal. So does the feeling of needing to go when there is nothing there. In children and teenagers, growth slowing, puberty arriving late and weight loss put down to being a teenager can be the whole picture, with the bowel part so mild that nobody looks.
Bloating that is flat first thing and enormous by evening. A lot of wind. Feeling full quickly. Symptoms that arrive after eating rather than at random. That pattern raises small intestinal bacterial overgrowth: more fermentation happening in the small intestine than belongs there, making gas where there is no room for it.
There are two patterns in it. The hydrogen one travels with wind and looser stools. The methane one, properly called intestinal methanogen overgrowth, travels with constipation. A meta-analysis across nineteen studies found constipation in 47 per cent of people with methanogen overgrowth against 38 per cent of controls, with bloating the commonest symptom of all at 78 per cent.
One practical consequence of that. Methanogens use up four molecules of hydrogen for every molecule of methane they make, so somebody with a methane pattern can have deceptively low hydrogen. A breath test measuring hydrogen alone can come back reassuring for exactly the person it should not.
Be careful what you take from a test here. Whether the breath test measures what it claims to is the subject of an open disagreement between specialist bodies. A positive result does not prove an overgrowth is causing your symptoms. A negative one does not prove it is not.
Here is the part that gets missed. Getting rid of an overgrowth and stopping it coming back are two different jobs, which is where most of the disappointment here comes from. Something let it build up in the first place. If that thing is still there afterwards, so is the problem.
So the question worth asking is what is going on underneath. What let the overgrowth happen? The underlying causes with real evidence behind them are a small intestine that moves things along too slowly, past bowel surgery, anything that slows the gut down such as diabetes or an underactive thyroid, opiate painkillers, the drying kind of medicines such as some older antihistamines or bladder tablets, plus months or years on acid-blocking tablets.
Underlying cause first, then the overgrowth, then the symptoms. Treatment that goes at the middle of that and leaves the first part alone tends not to last.
Endometriosis. If your gut is worse at the same point in every cycle, say that out loud. Pain opening your bowels during a period is one of the signs, as is pain deep inside during sex. A normal scan does not rule it out. Plenty of women are treated for IBS for years without once being asked about their periods.
Low iron and low B12 together, in somebody who eats carefully, is one question rather than two. Both are taken up in the gut and both depend on an intact lining. Two low results in a careful eater point at the surface rather than at the shopping.
Low stomach acid makes iron harder to absorb, which is worth knowing if you have been on acid-blocking tablets for a long time. Whether low iron itself lowers stomach acid is much less certain and is practitioner reasoning rather than settled.
A bowel that has never been right since a stomach bug, food poisoning or a course of antibiotics is its own thing, with its own evidence, further down this page.
Hypermobility. Connective tissue is everywhere rather than only in the joints, so bendy joints often arrive alongside gut symptoms, fatigue and light-headedness on standing up. If you could always do the party tricks, say so.
Some people get symptoms from gluten without having coeliac disease. Often it is the foggy, headachey, tired ones rather than the digestive ones. If you took gluten out and felt better, what you noticed is real.
The order still matters more than anything else in this section. Get the coeliac blood test first, while you are still eating gluten. Once it is out the antibodies fall, a negative result stops meaning much, then you have lost the chance to know. Coeliac disease is a different illness with different consequences, for your bones and your absorption among other things. It is worth knowing which one you have.
Two things could still turn out to explain some of this. Fructans, which are in wheat alongside the gluten and are one of the FODMAPs further down. Or expectation. Neither would be surprising. Neither makes what you noticed untrue.
If you have paid for a food intolerance test, this is what it measured. Most of them measure IgG antibodies to food proteins. IgG rises with exposure, so the result tells you that you eat a food rather than that you react to it. The professional bodies advise against using it this way. Somebody who eats bread every day will test positive to wheat whether or not it troubles them.
Acting on those results usually means removing a lot of foods at once, which risks nutritional gaps and makes finding the real problem harder. It is also difficult to reverse.
What actually establishes an intolerance is taking one food out, then putting it back, one at a time, with somebody who will do the putting back as well as the taking out.
Some things are not a reading. They are an appointment.
Blood in the stool. Weight falling without you trying. A change in bowel habit that starts after fifty and does not go back. Waking from sleep to open your bowels. A lump in the abdomen. Fever. Anaemia, or a family history of bowel or ovarian cancer.
Any one of those is a reason to be seen rather than a reason to read on.
Tests before you take anything off your plate. Coeliac blood test while you are still eating gluten. Ferritin and B12 actually measured rather than assumed. Faecal calprotectin if there is blood, urgency or weight loss.
Then the free things, for a fortnight: how you eat, plant variety, the breath before a meal.
Then the specific treatments, if the first two have not done it.
The commonest way this goes wrong is narrowing. Something causes symptoms, so it goes. Then something else goes. Six months later the diet is eight foods and the gut is worse than it was at the start, because the bacteria have been starved of the variety they were living on.
A long elimination diet started by somebody who is already anxious about food makes both ends worse. Where something genuinely needs removing, do it with a registered dietitian, who will put things back as well as take them out.
The bacteria in your large intestine do something your body cannot do for itself. They break down the fibre that arrives undigested. In doing it they make short-chain fatty acids, mostly butyrate, which is the favourite fuel of the cells lining the colon. A lining that is well fed holds together better and lets less through that was never meant to cross.
What changes this is dull and nearly free. The American Gut Project work on plant diversity and gut microbial diversity found that the number of different plants eaten in a week predicts the range of bacteria better than total fibre does. Thirty a week is the figure usually quoted. Plants here means whole foods rather than fruit: vegetables, nuts, seeds, beans, pulses, whole grains, herbs and spices all count, which makes it more reachable than it sounds. A bag of mixed frozen vegetables counts as several.
If several plants are exactly what sets you off, read the next part before you try this one. It is not a rule that fits everybody.
Go up slowly and with water. Adding fibre fast makes symptoms worse in a lot of people, which is how good advice gets abandoned in week one.
No microbiome test sold to the public can tell you what to eat. The useful action is the same whatever the test would have said. The test costs what a month of the useful action costs. Will Bulsiewicz writes about all of this at length in Fiber Fueled, which is food-led rather than supplement-led.
There is no one gut diet. Two people carrying the same label often need opposite things, which is why general advice fails one of them.
Some people react to a group of carbohydrates called FODMAPs: fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides and polyols. Onion, garlic, larger servings of wheat, most pulses, apples and pears, dairy containing lactose, honey and the polyol sweeteners are the usual ones. They are poorly absorbed, so they draw water into the gut and get fermented, which makes gas. For somebody like that, being told to eat thirty plants a week is being told to eat the thing that hurts.
A low FODMAP diet is a test rather than a way of eating. Monash University, who developed it, describe a strict phase of two to six weeks, then reintroduction over roughly eight to twelve weeks, testing one group at a time. Then the part that is the actual goal: the widest diet you can comfortably eat. The strict phase is the diagnostic half of it rather than the diet. Stopping there is the commonest way this goes wrong. Portion size matters more than people expect. The same food can be fine in one serving and a problem in a larger one, so treating it as a list of good and bad foods gets it wrong.
Feeling better on it does not mean anything has been cleared. Across nine studies, restriction consistently reduced one group of useful bacteria and lowered the overall quality of the diet, with several nutrients falling below what is recommended. Both recover when the diet is widened again, which is the argument for reintroduction rather than against the approach. And it is the wrong instrument altogether for anybody with a difficult relationship with food, or anybody losing weight without meaning to.
If bile acid malabsorption is the problem, the lever is fat rather than fibre. Bile is released to deal with fat, so less fat arriving means fewer bile acids reaching the colon. Bringing the fat down often brings a good deal of relief. That relief is useful twice over: it helps, then the fact that it helped points at this rather than at IBS. Do it alongside asking your doctor about the test rather than instead of it.
So the rule underneath all of it. Widen before you narrow. Change one thing at a time. Give each change a fortnight before you judge it. And do any removing with a registered dietitian, who will put foods back as well as take them out.
Digestion is run by the half of your nervous system that only works properly when nothing else is demanding attention. Blood goes to the gut. The stomach makes acid. The gallbladder empties. The other half does the opposite: blood to the muscles, gut slowed, the whole business postponed. Nobody can be in both at once.
So a meal eaten standing up between two tasks lands in a body that has not opened for business. Naturopathy makes a great deal of this. The mechanism underneath it is not in dispute.
Four things, none of which cost anything. Give them a fortnight, then decide.
Gut-directed hypnotherapy has evidence supporting its use in IBS and sits among guideline-based treatment options. Response rates in trials are good. Almost nobody is offered it, because there are few trained practitioners.
It is not relaxation and it is not a recording of waves. It works on the amplified signalling between gut and brain rather than on the gut itself, which is why it reaches symptoms that diet cannot. Ask for it by name. Ask whether the practitioner is trained in the gut-directed protocol specifically, because a general relaxation recording is not the same thing.
Here is what it is working on. Your gut sends information upwards all day: stretch, movement, acidity, what is arriving and how fast. You are aware of almost none of it, because the brain filters nearly all of it out before it reaches you. That filter is adjustable. What adjusts it is largely attention and expectation. A gut that has hurt for two years teaches the system that this is information worth passing on, so the filter opens. Signals that were always there start to arrive.
That is not the same as being told it is in your head. In your head means made up. This is a real change in a real system, it can be measured. It can also be changed.
It cuts both ways, which is the caution. Somebody whose filter is wide open can also have coeliac disease. Amplification does not rule out disease. Disease does not rule out amplification. Being told to relax while there is something to find is how people lose years.
There is one trial here worth knowing about, published in the journal Gut in 2019. A hundred and fifteen adults whose IBS with diarrhoea had begun after a gut infection were given either five grams of L-glutamine three times a day or a placebo, for eight weeks. Glutamine is the main fuel of the cells lining the small intestine, which is ordinary physiology rather than a claim.
Around eighty per cent of the glutamine group had a meaningful fall in symptom severity, against under six per cent on placebo. Measured gut permeability improved alongside it. Side effects ran under four per cent in both groups.
Now the reasons not to over-read it. It was a single centre. The effect was extraordinarily large. Results that large from one centre have a poor record of surviving repetition. The placebo response was unusually low for a bowel trial. And it was in one narrow group: people whose symptoms began after an infection. Nobody has shown this works for IBS in general.
So, fairly: if your gut has never been the same since a bug, this is a reasonable eight-week experiment, it is cheap as an unflavoured powder. It is one of the few things in this area with a proper trial behind it. Stop at eight weeks if nothing has changed. If your gut has always been difficult, the trial does not extend to you, which is not the same as knowing it will not help.
One real safety point. Glutamine is turned into ammonia. A liver that cannot clear ammonia can be tipped into confusion by it. Anybody with cirrhosis or a history of hepatic encephalopathy should not take this. Ask first if you have significant kidney disease.
Chinese medicine has read thinking and digesting as one job for two thousand years. It puts both under the Spleen, which is not the organ a surgeon would point at but the capacity to turn food into what the body runs on. That capacity is held to dislike cold, damp and worry. When it is weak the signs are heaviness after eating, loose stools and tiredness that is worse after a meal than before it. With those comes a mind that will not stop going round.
Ayurveda calls the same capacity agni, the digestive fire. It reads food that is only half transformed as leaving a residue called ama, which it holds responsible for heaviness, a coated tongue and a mind that will not clear. Ayurveda does not treat the mind as a separate department: a dull mind is read as a digestive matter until shown otherwise. Vasant Lad's Ayurveda: The Science of Self-Healing is the standard introduction.
What both of them actually tell somebody to do is unglamorous. Warm cooked food rather than cold and raw. Smaller amounts. The largest meal in the middle of the day. Regular times. A gap between meals rather than constant grazing, so one thing is finished before the next arrives. Eating sitting down, without a screen.
Two systems several thousand years apart, arriving at warm food at regular times and not while working, is the sort of agreement worth trying even if you accept neither explanation. A modern reading gets to most of the same instructions through meal timing, the rest-and-digest state and the body clock. The same advice turns up in modern dietetics for the months after gut surgery or infection.
One warning that matters more than the theory. Herbal formulas from either tradition can contain wheat, barley or malt, as an ingredient or as a binder in a tablet. Some of them interact with prescribed medication. Use a registered practitioner, who will check, rather than an internet order, which will not.
Three things, in this order. Get the tests done before you remove anything from your plate. Give the free things a fortnight. Then ask for the specific thing that fits what you found.
Before the first mouthful, breathe out slowly three times. Longer out than in.
It is the fastest switch there is between bracing and digesting. It takes about twenty seconds.
Sit down to eat.
Not as a ritual. For the blood flow, which goes to the gut in one state and to the muscles in the other.
Put the screen away.
Attention on a screen is attention on a problem. Your body cannot tell your inbox from something that needs running from.
Chew more than feels necessary.
Digestion starts in the mouth. Most people give it about a third of the work it is expecting.
One line a day is enough. Thirty seconds on your phone. This is deliberately not a food diary, because a food diary turns into a list of suspects.
Laid side by side for two weeks, those lines answer the question no test can answer for you. Symptoms that are there on calm days as much as bad days, that follow particular meals, point at the gut end. Symptoms that arrive in the hard weeks and ease in the quiet ones, whatever you ate, point at the other end. Plenty of people find both. That is a real answer rather than a failed one.
If a fortnight of this changes nothing, the state you eat in was not doing the work, which points the attention back at the gut itself. Go back to your GP and ask for three things by name: coeliac serology while you are still eating gluten, ferritin and B12, plus faecal calprotectin. If the problem is urgent watery stool and you have had your gallbladder out, ask about bile acid malabsorption specifically.
Nothing on this page is a reason to wait. Blood, weight you did not mean to lose, waking at night to open your bowels, a change in habit after fifty or a family history of bowel cancer all need a doctor now rather than in a fortnight.
Written from the Exist Better knowledge base: the studies, books and thinkers behind each claim, read through every discipline we hold rather than one. Where the research is early or still argued, the page says so rather than rounding it up. How we decide what goes in.
© Exist Better 2026. All rights reserved.